Casey Key real estate

Casey Key is a barrier island located off the coast of Sarasota. Casey Key is South of Siesta Key and runs all the way south into Venice. Casey Key is a very narrow island with beautiful beach front real estate. On Casey Key, you’ll also find Nokomis Public Beach, which is Sarasota County’s oldest public beach originally built in the 1950’s. Head over mainland from Casey Key to find Oscar Scherer State Park, Historic Spanish Point, and The Legacy Trail. View all active listings on Casey Key below. To see Casey Key real estate call/text Matt at 941-356-5377 or email Matt at

Casey Key

Click the links below to sort results by price range.
All Listings Over $1,000,000

Casey Key Statistics

Average Price $5.9M
Lowest Price $1.2M
Highest Price $12.5M
Total Listings 27
Avg. Days On Market 171
Avg. Price/SQFT $2.2K

Property Types (active listings)